About Reservoir Tavern

Reservoir Tavern is a Pizza restaurant located in the Boonton neighborhood at 90 Parsippany Blvd. (Rtes. 202 & 287) in Boonton, NJ 07005. Reservoir Tavern has been described as an Great Pizza restaurant and has received an average rating of 7.7 by our members.

Food

Decor

Service

User Reviews for Reservoir Tavern

All Reviews for Reservoir Tavern

  • Food

    9

    Decor

    9

    Service

    7

    When I was young my mom used to make me these really tasty meatballs and she's using a really off the hook sauce... I don't know how she do it but I really didn't care... I'm not a cook...:) what matters to me is that it taste perfect! When I first came to Reservoir a friend told me that it's a tavern to those who seek for mind blowing dishes... Well I was indeed blown away! They have the best tasting meatballs ever! My mom will definitely love this place... They are in AU now but once they visit me I will with no doubt bring her to this amazing place... m/

    I Ate:

    Overall Rating

    8.5

    "Amazing"

  • Food

    8

    Decor

    9

    Service

    6

    I am not really a fan of carbs but Reservoir changed it... I just can't resist their mouth watering pastas... My friends who are supposedly supporting me on my cause to "not to indulge" were tempted as well... What can I say... This place really rocks!

    I Ate:

    Overall Rating

    7.8

    "Great"

  • Food

    7

    Decor

    9

    Service

    6

    I love their pizza "ultimate"... Even if I have to wait 30-45 minutes before digging in to it, it's all worth... really affordable and still you get the best quality... My friends really love hanging out to this place because the atmosphere is awesome... This place is the bomb!

    I Ate:

    Overall Rating

    7.3

    "Great"

  • Christina Crimi

    Food

    9

    Decor

    6

    Service

    5

    This is one of the best brick oven pizza restaurants around. It is 2nd to Lombardi's (NYC) in my book. A very very very popular local restaurant. The bar is filled with locals as well as out of towners. On a typical Saturday night be prepared to wait (usually 30minutes to 1 hour and a half). They don't take reservations but you can call ahead to put your name on the list. The pizza is so good and the crust comes out airy and full with that perfect brick oven crispiness. The other menu items are really good too. The stuffed artichoke is huge and delicious. You also have to order the toasties if your sitting at the bar waiting for your table. Definitely worth the wait. They also do take-out but if you want your food by 6pm on a Friday night be sure to call by 430pm to take your place in line.

    I Ate:

    • Pizza: Perfect ($10)

    Overall Rating

    7.3

    "Great"