Brother Jimmys BBQ

Average User Rating

6.5

Exceptional

About Brother Jimmys BBQ

Brother Jimmys BBQ is a Southern restaurant located in the Upper West Side neighborhood at 428 Amsterdam Ave. (bet. 80th & 81st Sts.) in New York, NY 10024. Brother Jimmys BBQ has been described as an Exceptional Southern restaurant and has received an average rating of 6.5 by our members.

Quick Facts

Cuisine: Southern, BBQ
Accepts Credit Card: N/A
Parking: N/A

Atmosphere: N/A
Take Reservations: N/A
Serves Alcohol: N/A
Smoking Allowed:No

User Reviews for Brother Jimmys BBQ

food		“...I placed an order for delivery. It was delivered an over an hour later and when he finally arrived, he left again because he forgot some items... “... When we went, the atmosphere was very loud since there were college games on, so not sure if it is always like this, but I will definitely go back as the food was great... “...Thankfully we weren't watching a very popular football game because we got seating for all 5 of without even blinkin. The food was really good overall... “... What an idiot I was. The food is absolutely disgusting... “...Great burgers! Fries are only okay. Go with the tator tots...
ambiance		“...I LOVE the food at Brother Jimmys. The dry rub ribs are one of the best things I've ever eaten in NYC... “...I have heard about this restaurant, and finally tried it. The bbq ribs are really good and one must try the pulled pork... “...Brother Jimmy's has OK BBQ and some decent specials. The only problem is it's filled with every person I couldn't stand in college... “...I ate here the other day after having a bad experience over a year ago. I vowed to not go back but somehow was convinced to go... “...wow - a nice idea, but SCARY experience! Dirty, and the environment is a turn-off!...
value		“...Great BBQ for a great price! And you can't beat their speacilty sauces that they leave on the table.... “...Thankfully we weren't watching a very popular football game because we got seating for all 5 of without even blinking. The food was really good overal...
chicken		“... So now its an hour and a half . The candied yams were raw, the iced tea was warm, the chicken wings were not red-hot and the blue cheese was tasteless... “...This is a great sports bar.... “...Brother JImmy's is supposed to be a B. The other day I ordered BBQ wings for an appetizer and a grilled chicken sandwhich with fries for my main course...

All Reviews for Brother Jimmys BBQ

Alexis

November 06, 2007

Food

8

Decor

8

Service

8

Every time I feel like I just want a relax with a beer, catch a Sunday game or take a trip down south this is the first place that pops into mind. Talk about BBQ, Brother Jimmy's really does it right! Jimmy's has a very laid back , pub/family style and college town feel to it. I've been a fan of Brother Jimmy's since the age of 8 when I use to visit their Chicago location monthly with family. Their menu has everything that good BBQ can offer along with all the good fixings. Their mac and cheese is an all around favorite along with their sweet BBQ wings and ribs. If family or friends are in town I'd suggest hitting this fun country spot up!

Overall Rating

8

"Great"
Colleen
December 04, 2008

Food

5

Decor

5

Service

5

This is a great college bar and a great place to hang out with friends. The food is typical bar food - it's good, but not the main draw. They have a lot of TVs for watching sports and it's a great place to go to watch the game. It gets packed Thursday, Friday and Saturday nights, so if you're planning to go then, you should go early.

I Ate:
Overall Rating

5

"Average"