About Carmine's

Last Updated: Dec 11, 2014
Carmine's is a Italian restaurant located at 2450 Broadway in New York, NY 10024. Carmine's has been described as an Perfect Italian restaurant and has received an average rating of 9.5 by our members. Italian Cuisine is known for its pasta dishes.

Additional Info

Nearest Transit: 86 St (1, 2) 96 St (1, 2, 3) 86 St (A, B, C) Good for Kids: Yes Good for Groups: Yes Delivery: Yes Take Out: Yes Waiter Service: Yes Outdoor Seating: No Wifi: No Good For: Dinner Alcohol Description: Full Bar Noise Level: Average Ambience: Casual Has TV: Yes Caters: Yes

Food

Decor

Service

User Reviews for Carmine's

All Reviews for Carmine's

food
  • It was a group and Carmines specializes in Family style for groups. What can I say, Past: overcooked...
  • While I agree with the other reviews in that you can find more authentic (less Americanized) Italian in the city, I still thought Carmine's was a worth-while experience...
  • First time at Carmine's and the food and service were excellent. You will not leave hungary!...
  • Awesome food. Large portions...
  • We were recently in NYC and stumbled across Carmine's while on our way to our favorite Chinese resturant.Carmine's was celebrating their 20th anniversa...
  • The manager stopped over to our table during our meal and made friendly conversa. The food is what you pay for, loaded with butter and comes out quick...
ambiance
  • Theater District. You actually feel like they want you there and enjoy serving the...
  • Always a go-to spot when the parents are in for a visit. The bartenders & staff are always great, the Frozen Cosmo is one of their specialties, and wh...
  • Carmines has great food even when you take out. The noise is part of the atmosphere, most italian resturaunts are noisy...
service
  • Good Italian cuisine with friendly service visited mostly by theater goers....
  • It is worth noting, both when considering just dropping in without reser. As the restaurant filled up, the service became slower, but not unreasonable...
value
  • If you like good italian food, don't waste your time and money here when there are many awesome places in NYC. Seriously the quality is on par with the...
  • Don't order the shrimp scampi - it wasn't worth the price....
  • Pricey but really a value for NYC, based on the size of the portions. Our family made reservations in July for a dinner the week after Christmas, so...
family
  • Their sommelier took ti. The family-style portions ended up being reasonably priced (~$40-50 for an entree with pasta added will easily feed 4 people)...
  • My boyfriend and I enjoyed Carmine's so much that we plan to be going there for years. The food was so good that we took the leftovers home and had the...
  • The bartenders & staff are always great, the Frozen Cosmo is one of their specialties, and when they say they serve family style, they mean family style! The dishes are enormous! And the food is great! If you want a treat, the Lobster Fra Diavolo is pricey but worth the money spent! I would also recommend the chicken parm...
  • ONE TASTE and we were HOOKED-we abandoned our plans and made a quick detour into Carmine's-ABSOL.-out of this world!! Huge portions-served family style...
portions
  • This is the 'Olive Garden' of NY. Massive portions are it's only charm...
  • Food is good but portions are huge, definitely, a place for large groups eating family style....
  • Pros: big portions to share family style. Great for groups of friends...
restaurant
  • The fam. We arrived as shows were starting, caught the restaurant during its turnover from theatre crowd to evening crowd, and were seated immediately...
  • this restaurant is fantastic. the food is served family style and there is always plenty...
  • We were wandering Times Square looking for a restaurant. Our hotel sent us to a restaurant with a pending rating and only one table filled...
  • This restaurant is purposefully designed to be as loud as possible - no carpet, no acoustic ceiling tile just lots of hard surfaces enclosing a cavernous space so that every sound is magnified and you can't shout loud enough to be heard by the person seated next to you...
  • Carrie McCully

    Food

    10

    Decor

    9

    Service

    9

    Large portions, delicious food, exceptional service. The place to go to with your family /friends!

    I Ate:

    • Rigatoni Country Style: Amazing, huge family style portions that easily feeds 2-4 people. ($18)

    Overall Rating

    9.5

    "Perfect"