Croton Reservoir Tavern

Average User Rating

Average

About Croton Reservoir Tavern

The Croton Reservoir Tavern is an American restaurant and bar with a palpable turn of the century feel that recalls the days of cobblestone streets and horse drawn carriages. The Tavern was named in honr of the Croton Reservoir, one of Manhattan's forgotten landmarks. Once the city's main water source, the basin was filled in to lay the foundation for the New York Public Library and Bryant Park. The Cosmopolitan American cuisine is perfect for lunch or dinner. New York's best service staff will make you feel at home while the skilled bartenders pour you only the best drink you desire.

Quick Facts

Cuisine: American
Accepts Credit Card: Yes
Parking: N/A

Atmosphere: N/A
Take Reservations: Yes
Serves Alcohol: N/A
Smoking Allowed:No

User Reviews for Croton Reservoir Tavern

food		“... Our food arrived pretty fast. The burger was cooked exactly medium rare though I felt the giant brioche bun was slightly over-sized for the small beef... “...Great lunch option or after work pub.... “...If I liv. Had Thanks Giving dinner with family at the tavern and right away I felt at home, the food is good and the bar tender was like my big brother... “...What happened to this place? Used to be a good place for lunch; but when the hostess can't seem to pull herself away from leaning on the podium to greet diners...
ambiance		“...Had lunch here today. Tried the house made hummus and the angus burger with sweet potato fries... “...A Wonderful place. We had reservations for 6pm and arrived at 5:20 and sat at the bar for a drink... “...If I lived in NYC, I might make this my Friday night hang out. Had Thanks Giving dinner with family at the tavern and right away I felt at home, the fo...
service		“... Tried the house made hummus and the angus burger with sweet potato fries. service was pretty quick even though the place was packed with people... “...We had our Thanksgiving dinner at this restaurant while visiting NYC, and the service and food was great, aside from the fact that it did not break our wallets... “...WOW! What an overwhelming disappointment this place is! Came here yesterday for a business lunch. The place seemed clean enough but had the unmistakab... “... The atmosphere is a little bit noisy but the food is excellent. The waitress was friendly and the service was good...
value		“...We each had the price fixe dinner. I had the salmon, and my lady had the skirt steak... “...My date and I enjoyed a fantastic meal before a broadway show. The food was fantastic and the prices were reasonable... “...The downstairs lounge is a fun happy hour spot, but this place isn't one that you should go out of your way for. Sliders were pretty small, even for s... “...Food quality is excellent - their beef entrees are best followed by dessert concoctions....
drinks		“... When it didn't look like we were going to mak. He even donned a gangster hat while serving the drinks, and I swear I caught him dancing more than once... “... We had reservations for 6pm and arrived at 5:20 and sat at the bar for a drink. The drinks were very good... “... Had Thanks Giving dinner with family at the tavern and right away I felt at home, . The wine selection is good and the drinks well, they're the drinks... “...I wasn't expecting the food here to be good. I went in there to meet up with friends for drinks and afterwards, we sat down to eat...
steak		“... I had the salmon, and my lady had the skirt steak. The portions, flavor, and presentation were wonderful beyond belief! The service was excellent, our... “... maybe it was just the fact that we were there. We had all four specials and only the ravioli was decent; not the turkey (canned?), steak, or swordfish... “...This is a bar, with an inexplicably overpriced menu. The hamburger is $19... “... Come on! You're not cheap, your diners deser. The burgers and steak meat was still good, but the rolls and buns were burned and the slaw was the worst...
waiter		“... I h. The portions, flavor, and presentation were wonderful beyond belief! The service was excellent, our waiter Chad II was friendly and knowledgeable... “...Our waiter was not great, drinks were empty for a while and he didn't serve my mom her appetizer with the rest of the table. But the food was very good... “... For starters the waiter was surly and aggressive and did a horrible job of hiding his contempt for everyone of his customers. When I ordered a seltze...