rd rd

About Eataly

Eataly is a Italian restaurant located at 200 Fifth Ave. (23rd St.) in New York, NY 10003. Eataly has been described as an Perfect Italian restaurant and has received an average rating of 9.7 by our members. Italian Cuisine is known for its pasta dishes.

Quick Facts

  • Cuisine: Italian
  • Accepts Credit Card: Yes
  • Parking: N/A
  • Atmosphere: N/A
  • Take Reservations: Yes
  • Serves Alcohol: N/A
  • Smoking Allowed:No

User Reviews for Eataly

food

“...I will say that I love the food offerings - lots of yummy pastas, pizza, fish, meat, paninis, desserts, restaurants, etc....

ambiance

“...My friend and I were in there a few days ago and i think I believe service wise, the employees that get one-on one time with customers are polite ad patient for the most part but, when it comes to management, they seem to lack what the other employees have, i saw a cashier go out of her way to wrap a customers book in cardboard because he was on a bike and didn't want the book to get damaged, the manager was on the floor and yelled at the poor girl because she was running around asking for a small box, since she couldn't find one she went to get a huge box and a box cutter and improvised...

service

“... The place was hard to navigate at first, what with the flood o. We eventually secured a table at La Pasta where we were treated to very prompt service...

value

“...But the space is SO poorly designed, it's like they weren't at ALL choiceful in what they wanted to do - they just did everything so it's so packed you can barely walk...

restaurant  

“...Staff is very nice in general but we had bad luck and the hostess at the pizza restaurant screamed at us! There are many options in the city where you can get great pizza, fresh pasta and Italian groceries so I might just go back for the fig gelato!...

menu  

“...Well right before we left my friend goes back and asked another cashier if they take EBT cards, she said not at the moment, and we said Whole Foods takes EBT, the cashier literally looked both ways and said a lot of customers and employees asked the same thing and when this was brought to attention of one of the "head honchos" straight from Italy, he didn't know what it was and they explained that its a gov't program for people that are either unemployed, or don't make enough money and need assistance, and that this guys response was "Oh, poor people can go buy somewhere else", when we heard this our jaws dropped, the cashier said she took offense to this since her disabled elderly mother receives this "poor people help", she said she doesn't spend a penny in that store since then, And i don't think i will either...

wine  

“... The pizza was good but nothing you couldn't get at other Italian restaurants in t. The wine list, especially on the value/quality category is not good...

All Reviews for Eataly

  • September 06, 2010

    Food

    9

    Decor

    9

    Service

    10

    This place opened just recently and I was absolutely grateful to get a taste of real Italian cuisines! I couldn't agree more, so far the best and the chefs are great plus,plus,plus!

    I Ate:

    Overall Rating

    9.3

    "Perfect"

  • December 05, 2011

    Food

    10

    Decor

    10

    Service

    10

    The meal in Eataly has been a first rate experience. So... The other day I visited Eataly in New York City. Now I am orginally from Tokyo though have been to N.Y. a considerable number of instances. I really enjoy the variety of eateries. I discovered Eataly as polished all the way, from style through the presentation. Such a pleasurable and joyful dinnerService in that restaurant was very nice! The event was fantastic. The order arrived really quick. The superior quality and also amount of food turned out great. Regardless of that no true issues. My friends and I had a great evening! So refreshing as there are lots of NYC restaurants that are lousy. I'm a huge fan of the place.

    Overall Rating

    10

    "Perfect"

rd rd