About Mickey Mantles

Mickey Mantles is a American restaurant located in the Midtown West neighborhood at 42 Central Park S. (bet. 5th & 6th Aves.) in New York, NY 10019. Mickey Mantles has been described as an Good American restaurant and has received an average rating of 5 by our members.

Food

Decor

Service

User Reviews for Mickey Mantles

All Reviews for Mickey Mantles

food
  • Had lunch with my wife and 6 year old . The wings where overcooked and dry with sauce just splattered on ...
  • I went here with my family a few weeks ago, and had a great experience!! It has a great view of Central Park. Definitely get the spinach dip, the phill...
  • You have to know that you're not going for the food. It's fun to see baseball memorabilia from Mick's era, lots of visiting teams hang out there, and ...
ambiance
  • I work in Central Park and USED to go here often on Sunday evenings for food and drink and to watch football. The food is OK but overpriced (expected ...
  • My wife and two boys went to Mickey's after a day at the stadium and it was much better than the dated reviews would have you believe. They apparently ...
  • Aw, cmon, have a little fun. The Mick would have...
service
  • Soft drinks came 90% ice and they charge full price for refills . service was good...
  • They were DELICIOUS! Better than any I've had, in fact. The service was excellent...
  • It's fun to see baseball memorabilia from Mick's era, lots of visiting teams hang out there, and with low expectations, the food, decor, and service are actually pretty good...
memorabilia
  • This was one of the most fabulous dining experiences that we have ever had. From the moment that my husband, my daughter and I arrived, it was an excep...
  • Yeah this was a let down! The service was bad, a mean you could really tell the waitress hates her life and makes sure everyone knows it! I had some calamari that where not good at all...
  • The burgers are excellent as was the yell. The sports memorabilia kept the boys busy and overall it was a very pleasant experience in a great location...