Paul & Jimmys

Average User Rating

Average

About Paul & Jimmys

Paul & Jimmys is a Italian Northern restaurant located in the Gramercy Park neighborhood at 123 E. 18th St. (bet. Irving Pl. & Park Ave. S.) in New York, NY 10010. Paul & Jimmys has been described as an Good Italian Northern restaurant and has received an average rating of 5 by our members.

Quick Facts

Cuisine: Italian Northern, Italian Southern
Accepts Credit Card: N/A
Parking: N/A

Atmosphere: N/A
Take Reservations: N/A
Serves Alcohol: N/A
Smoking Allowed:No

User Reviews for Paul & Jimmys

food		“...The restaurant was very accommodating and eager to please. The food is good but not great... “...I've been coming to Paul and Jimmy's for years and I must say, the restaurant is only getting better. The waiters are authetic Italian men who love the... “...We came to this restaurant a few years ago (we live in NJ) and any time we. The food is fabulous and it's very warm and cozy with a very friendly staff... “...In a class by itself, no one in NYC is doing this kind of food, Creative, Delicious, Beautiful...
ambiance		“...I lived in CHelsea for twenty years and didnt know about this place!... “...We came to this restaurant a few years ago (we live in NJ) and any time we get into the City - we make sure we stop in for a meal. The food is fabulous... “...Corton is in a word, OUTSTANDING. We were treated to several extraordinary amuse bouches and as much delicious bread as we could eat...
service		“...The food was quite good, and the room is nice. But the waiter was awful--he wasn't just rude--he went out of his way to be nasty... “...Okay, I want to preface the review I am about to write by saying that I feel a little guilty writing a bad review on Thanksgiving, a day where one should be conscious of those who go hungry... “...wonderful food -- intriguing and delicious taste combinations; attentive but not overpowering service,; attractive plating; the three course dinner is ever so much more than that with all of the lovely additional offerings -- enough but not too much to eat; truly a great experience...
value		“...Being from CA, we don't have very many places like Paul and Jimmy's. It's a little dusty in terms of decor- I hate fake flowers and cheesy paintings...
atmosphere		“... The waiters were attentive but not overbearing. If you want a low key, quiet atmosphere, this is for you... “... There's something on the menu for everyone and the prix f. Its a tight squeeze between tables on the weekends but that just adds to the fun atmosphere... “...had to ask for several times for certain request. The place is a little tight but the atmosphere overall is charming...
veal		“... We started with the stuffed mushrooms and fried zucc. Moved on to Spaghetti Carbonara for the wife and a veal Rollatini for me, both equally wonderful... “... I also enjoyed the eggplant rollatini, calamari and stuffed mushrooms. For an entree I went with the veal scalloppine sorentina which was delish... “...Had a large party on Mothers day. First of all I had the veal special which was out of this world...
chicken		“... And, the food is what I like to think my mo. The pasta is well prepared and very satisfying but so are the meat dishes such as the chicken scapariello... “...I liked it. We sat at the bar and had amazing calamari, salmon, red wine... “... and he's so hard to please- so I'm happy if he's happy. We usually order something like the chicken parm...