Petaluma

Average User Rating

Perfect

About Petaluma

Petaluma is a Italian Northern restaurant located in the Upper East Side neighborhood at 1356 First Ave. (73rd St.) in New York, NY 10021. Petaluma has been described as an Perfect Italian Northern restaurant and has received an average rating of 10 by our members.

Quick Facts

Cuisine: Italian Northern, Italian Southern
Accepts Credit Card: N/A
Parking: N/A

Atmosphere: N/A
Take Reservations: N/A
Serves Alcohol: N/A
Smoking Allowed:No

User Reviews for Petaluma

food		“... My only ?complaints? (albeit minor ones) were that there was virtually no time to digest between courses as the food was served too fast, and there seemed to be a persistent effort on the part of management to turn tables as quickly as possible - they constantly hovered over the diners, trying to determine when the next table would become available... “...Very nice antipasto; the complimentary olives (served breaded) were appreciated. We were also provided with - on the house- small glasses of Proseco at... “...Nice place and pretty good food. The friend olives were amazing... “...This place has taken a nose dive into mediocrity in the last year. Used to be dependable neighborhood joint but now it is just your average overpriced ... “...Very consistent, reasonably priced, good neighborhood Italian restaurant. Menu has changed and is a nice improvement...
ambiance		“...My wife and I recently took our kids (ages 9 and 11) to Petaluma on a Saturday night. I am always wary of restaurants labeled as ?kid friendly?, and I ... “...A good place to gather if you want to enjoy unhurried service and quiet conversation with fellow guests.... “...Good neighborhood Italian. Good homemade pastas...
service		“... We were also provided with - on the house- small glasses of Proseco at the end of the meal. Overall this was enjoyable, good service... “...We decided to take a chance on a new restaurant for our anniversary. Petaluma is not far from our apartment on appealing street corner... “...This place has taken a nose dive. Used to be dependable neighborhood joint but now it is just your average overpriced average Italian with poor service... “... Good homemade pastas. service is wonderful; staff is very friendly...
value		“...Very professional staff and great Italian cuisine. We celebrated my friend's birthday party there last week and we were very happy with the service... “...Appreciated "value Wine" recommendation. We ordered a wonderful Portuguese wine for $30... “...The food was under cooked and the MGR does not know how to fix a problem! Portion was very small but the price was very large! who new a plate of paste with nothing on it could be priced at $17... “...Popular low keyed neighborhood italian restaurant that's been around for a long time. So they must be doing something right...
restaurant		“... I am always wary of restaurants labeled as ?kid friendly?, and I try despera. This well-appointed restaurant on the upper East Side did not disappoint... “...An excellent restaurant that you can always count on for outstanding food and high quality service. Set up that you can hold a conversation without hav... “... The friend olives were amazing. I come from the town the restaurant was named for so had to try it... “...this ids one of the best restaurants i have ever been to this actually was my first time goi. The food was delicious i highly recommend this restaurant...
staff		“... Once seated, however, the management and staff could not have been more pleasant and accommodating to my family (the chef even made my daughter?s favorite pasta dish despite the fact that it was not on the menu)... “...We thoroughly enjoyed our brunch--many good choices and a friendly staff.... “... White table cloths, candles, low lights, etc. The wait staff is friendly and efficient...
pasta		“... We had ravioli stuffed with veal, pine nuts, raisins in a sag. The pasta was not cooked all the way through, tough on the outside, mushy in the center... “... My steak was HUGE and came with fries, I would have much preferred a smaller steak and some vegetables or other sid. My husband's pasta came unadorned... “... I don't know if they've changed anything, but the food tastes better than ever. I salivate over their homemade pasta...

All Reviews for Petaluma

Anonymous

December 05, 2011

Food

10

Decor

10

Service

10

Let me just say I am a major gourmet. How to begin? Recently, traveling I went to Petaluma in NY. I discovered Petaluma as trendy entirely, from decor through the appearance. The staff in that restaurant was really great! The decor was remarkable. The entrees showed up very fast. Probably one of my issues had been the plating wasn't that remarkable. It was fine but failed to present you with that amaze vibe. Now the great quality as well as amount of food was great. Even though no serious issues. From the 2 apps and Two entrees we ordered, We'd say 3 as extremely good and One as pretty okay Visit right now prior to when the media hype gets ridiculous.

Overall Rating

10

"Perfect"