Quality Meats

Average User Rating

Great

About Quality Meats

Quality Meats is a American restaurant located in the Midtown West neighborhood at 57 W. 58th St. (bet. 5th & 6th Aves.) in New York, NY 10019. Quality Meats has been described as an Great American restaurant and has received an average rating of 8 by our members.

Quick Facts

Cuisine: American, Steakhouse
Accepts Credit Card: N/A
Parking: N/A

Atmosphere: N/A
Take Reservations: N/A
Serves Alcohol: N/A
Smoking Allowed:No

User Reviews for Quality Meats

food		“...I went here after I had an allergic reaction to too much salt so the Doctor told me, no added sodium in my diet. I told the wait staff of my condition ... “...Lunch was absolutely delicious. Everything, from the caesar salad, to the hanger steak and desert were prepared carefully and presented beautifully... “...One of the best steak houses in NYC. The corn is the best side...
ambiance		“...I guess you could say I am a sort of Steakhouse Connoisseur. I really love meat... “... Things started off promising - wonderful decor/ambiance (a bit on the dark side, though) noise level was high, but not too intrusive as to prevent having a conversation - Very friendly staff... “...Funky decor that really felt unique in mid-town. Staff recommended a great Argentinian Malbec that paried superbly with the porterhouse for two which w...
service		“... Despite this being a "steak house" don't hesitate to go with eaters of all kinds. service is terrific and fun bar scene too... “...I eat out alot and always check reviews of restaurants before I go - I am always interested to see what the people who frequent places think first-hand, which is why I wanted to write this review... “...Made reservation for a large group on a Sat night, but still had to wait for nearly 45 mins. service was attentive and helpful...
value		“... They do a very generous pour so you don't need more than a glass for the latter portion of dinner. Check it out, good value for what you get... “... Wine was $200, but the rest was just food and tip. So, while there is nothing WRONG with QM, it is a very poor value...
steak		“... Brought a friend from Kentucky who knows her ste. They do my favorite steak, hanger, more than justice, served with a fresh cherry sauce in the summer... “... Everything, from the caesar salad, to the hanger steak and desert were prepared carefully and presented beautifully. I highly recommend this spot for ... “... The wait staff was very friendly and helpful - made some great suggest. I had the 3 filet choice as my entre and it was cooked the way steak should be...
steaks		“... I love the bust of the bull in the front and the grand mirror, and they. Their steaks are of course excellent, and their specials are always just that... “...As a non-meat eating person I love this restaurant!!! The fish is outstanding and the side. My friend had one of the steaks and he raved about his meal... “... Our server also came around with oth. Now that's how to order wine! Around our table, we ordered everything from oysters to salmon, steaks and more... “...Alas, then the steaks came out, and things went downhill! My sirloin was cold - sent it back, and when I finally got it, and took a bite - it was tough, fatty and chewy - even with the large steak knife, I had to saw away - it was on the small side, too... “... Mushrooms finished with a splash of sherry are terrific. steaks and salads are good, but not as good as at their cheaper sister, Smith and Wollensky...
wine		“...Traditional steakhouse meets uptown class. One cannot go wrong at Quality Meats; the service is seamless and attentive, without crossing into overbeari... “...The outside is quite bright yet the inside is warm and cozy - yet spacious! Much nicer ambience than I expected.... “... New York strip i think is there best cut. wine prices are a little high... “...I think I have eaten at just about every well known steak restaurant in the city, so it was time to finally add Quality Meats to my list. Arrived with ... “...The best crab cake in town. We order 2 each, and skip a main course...

All Reviews for Quality Meats

Monica

February 20, 2008

Food

6

Decor

6

Service

6

Got takeout from Quality Meats (Smith Wollensky) learned that they truly have great cuts of delicious meats. Slight issues with price (of course, if only we could all afford the best cuts of pork, beef and fish). My main gripe with the place is that they are a steak house. I always dream (wish) that american food can be seen as more than just faux steak (argentinean) or faux pasta (Italian). Next time I get a Buffet or a gates to pay I'll make sure to go to another SW place, for my reality, save the dollars and go to yoru local market, and skin it yourself. You can then find some quality meats.

Overall Rating

6

"Good"
Anonymous

December 05, 2011

Food

10

Decor

10

Service

10

So... Recently, on a trip I visited Quality Meats in New York. Such a pleasant and contented dinnerEveryone at the restaurant amazingly nice!The space is clean and pretty. The evening was superb. The order came out very quick. My friends and I had a fantastic night! So refreshing since there are numerous NYC dining places that are awful. Also was to experience NYC eating place without a lot attitude. I'm a enormous lover of the place.

Overall Rating

10

"Perfect"