Rothmanns

Average User Rating

Perfect

About Rothmanns

Rothmanns is a Steakhouse restaurant located in the Upper East Side neighborhood at 3 E. 54th St. (bet. 5th & Madison Aves.) in New York, NY 10021. Rothmanns has been described as an Perfect Steakhouse restaurant and has received an average rating of 10 by our members.

Quick Facts

Cuisine: Steakhouse
Accepts Credit Card: N/A
Parking: N/A

Atmosphere: N/A
Take Reservations: N/A
Serves Alcohol: N/A
Smoking Allowed:No

User Reviews for Rothmanns

food		“...We visit Rothmanns at least once a year. They service is very good and the food is always plentyflu and delish... “... however, we were very disappointed. both food and service were very off... “... We were greeted and escorted to the bar by the maitre'd whose smarm level was . Meh, should have no bearing on the food, but was somewhat offputting... “... I even take myself to lunch sometimes when I need a total break fr. I find the food consistently delicious and the service very friendly and efficient... “...I found it to be vastly overpriced with inferior steaks compared to many of the older more established steakhouses in the city. I went there for lunch ...
ambiance		“...Exquisite from start to finish. For those not intimidated by a menu full of culinary delights balanced by a profoundly rich and insightful wine list an... “...THE SERVICE WAS QUITE POOR. WE WERE A PARTY OF TWO SURROUNDED BY LARGER PARTIES THAT GOT NEARLY ALL OF THE ATTENTION OF THE WAIT STAFF... “...Yes, I should Yelp more often. I should also exercise more and dress better... “...Have eaten here a few times. Each time was great...
service		“...Rothmann's Sunday brunch was a wonderful experience. The presentation was terrific and there was a large variety of choices... “...One of the top rib-eye steak in Manhattan....
value		“...Admittedly I can't really taste a difference between the steak at Wolfgang's and the steak at Peter Luger's.... “...Quality operation....
steak		“... Although I would suggest a steak (the perfectly seasoned Porterhouse for two would be impressive for a date)they also tout delicious fowl and seafood to satify the most finnicky... “...It was very good, but wish there menu had more then just steak.... “... And for those of you thinking "dude, don't go to a steak house and order fish" I would say that despite the obligatory "how's your rib eye" questions, no one seemed sincere when answering a tepid "nice, how's yours?" 20 minutes is also too long to wait for a water glass refill... “... The first time (18 months ago) I went here, it was the best steak I've had, but my recent trip was one of the worst! What has happened here?! The steak was dry, rather tastless...
steaks		“...as usual, very good steaks, perfectly cooked. Great service until we had to wait for the check... “... Took kids here and they were treated like kings. Bone in ribeye was one of best steaks I've ever had... “.... I looked around and saw many half-eaten steaks being cleaned up after customers have finished eating...
restaurant		“... THE PORTERHOUSE FOR TWO, A STAPLE OF THE restaurant THAT WE HAVE BEEN GOING TO FOR YEARS, WAS NOTICEABLY SMALLER AND FULL OF FAT THAT I HAD TO REMOVE BEFORE EATING... “... I was fully expecting a really expensive experience, but compared to other steak houses it. I went with some selections from the restaurant Week menu... “...This restaurant has lost its way and gone downhill in terms of food quaility. The first time (18 months ago) I went here, it was the best steak I've ha...

All Reviews for Rothmanns

Anonymous

December 05, 2011

Food

10

Decor

10

Service

10

The dinner in Rothmanns was a pretty good experience. Yesterday I ate at Rothmanns in NY. I am from Toronto although have been to NY a bunch of times. My partner and I absolutely adore the distinctiveness of cafes. I found Rothmanns as tasteful all the way up, from the decor through the presentation. The staff at this particular restaurant surprisingly great!The dining room is clean and pretty. The event was excellent. Even though no serious issues. From the 2 starter items and 2 entrees we ordered, I probably would rate 3 as great -n- 1 as extremely okay Also was to go to a NYC restaurant not having a lot of attitude. Visit right now before the viral buzz gets crazy. We definitely will be back soon.

Overall Rating

10

"Perfect"