Shellys

Average User Rating

7.5

Great

About Shellys

Shellys is a Seafood restaurant located in the Midtown West neighborhood at 41 W. 57th St. (bet. 5th & 6th Aves.) in New York, NY 10019. Shellys has been described as an Great Seafood restaurant and has received an average rating of 7.5 by our members.

Quick Facts

Cuisine: Seafood, Steakhouse
Accepts Credit Card: N/A
Parking: N/A

Atmosphere: N/A
Take Reservations: N/A
Serves Alcohol: N/A
Smoking Allowed:No

User Reviews for Shellys

food		“... There was a jazz band playing on the balcony above the bar which was a really nice touch. The food was amazing and everyone was really friendly... “...The Restaurant Week menu was fantastic!... “...As of December 2010, this place was still open. We were there for a large 50+ person dinner and started with drinks in the upstairs area and then mo... “...I stopped in with 3 friends around 11pm for coffee. From the start things went down hill... “...Bartender was snobby and gave us the get the hell out vibe the moment we sat at the bar.It would've been better had I never gotten what I ordered...
ambiance		“...We went on Valentine's day and it was great. There was a jazz band playing on the balcony above the bar which was a really nice touch...
service		“...Went there for my wifes birthday. The food was excellent... “...Good food, good service and great portions! Definitely a neighborhood gem! I'll be back!(In the voice of Arnold Schwarzenegger)... “... The service was absolutely unacceptable. We were treated curtly and coldly until he finally handed me back the check with my credit card in it and I f... “... This place is a joke for the price vs quality. In regard to service I felt like a black student in 1965 at a white school by the wait staff...
value		“...I was at first skeptical of a restaurant that offered reasonable prices in the tourist district.A price fixe dinner that includes an abundant Oyster an... “...Our family dinner was very disappointing. The quality of the food was very poor... “...One of the best dinners I had in new york!! The small Cobb was so fresh & extremely tasty, the bolognese sauce was one of the best i've ever had!! Reasonably price service was great...
shelly's		“... The food was amazing and everyone was really friendly. We would definately recommend shelly's to couples... “...We had one of our best meals in New York at shelly's. Service was fantastic, and the food was great... “...Walked for miles with my family and landed on shelly's for lunch. My feet were tired... “...Just dined at shelly's on Saturday and was with 3 others. We had the Fresca pizza and fried calamari... “...This was my second visit to shelly's. Starters included Caprese and wonderfully tender Fried Calamari, with the main course being Fillet Mignonettes (s...
restaurant		“...Shelly's on 57th Street is one of New York's most beautiful restaurants. No design feature has been left un-noticed by the Architects/designers... “...Was really looking forward to eating here. We walked in and were seated by a bartender who was in the middle of pouring someone else a drink... “... Nowhere near worth the premium prices paid. If you're looking for a nice restaurant for a special occasion, you could do a lot better...
steak		“...A price fixe dinner that includes an abundant Oyster and shellfish. The porterhouse steak is grilled in butter to give a delicious crust and juicy meat... “... This was not a change of ownership and the great wait staff is still. Was mostly Italian, and now it's more steak, with a wine/coffee bar in the front... “... Spying on my neighbor's table, the pizza looked appeal. Outside of pizza, there's a respectable steak and chops section but only four pasta selections... “... DELICIOUS. steak, pasta and shrimp was had by others...

All Reviews for Shellys

Colleen
December 04, 2008

Food

7

Decor

8

Service

8

Shelly's is known for its raw bar and its seafood. The restaurant feels very airy spread over 2 floors. Their seafood is fresh and the menu offers a lot of options. The waitstaff is attentive and the bar is a pleasant place to wait for your table. I enjoyed my meal and wouldn't hesitate to go back.

I Ate:
Overall Rating

7.5

"Great"