Rusty Anchor: A Rustic Seafood Haven in Key West

Nestled in Stock-Island, just five miles away from the bustling city of Key West, lies Rusty Anchor, a seafood restaurant that boasts a rustic, low-lit ambiance that perfectly complements its nautical decor. With a saltwater tank that houses some of the freshest catches, including stone crabs in season, Rusty Anchor has become a go-to dining spot for seafood lovers in the area.

Led by the talented Chef, Rusty Anchor's menu features an array of mouth-watering seafood dishes that are sure to please even the most discerning palates. Here are some of the must-try menu items:

Blackened Grouper: A perfectly cooked fillet of grouper that is seasoned with a blend of spices and seared to perfection.
Grilled Shrimp: Succulent shrimp that are char-grilled to perfection, served with a side of garlic butter.
Lobster Bisque: A creamy soup that is loaded with chunks of tender lobster meat, garnished with parsley.
Stone Crab Claws: Freshly caught stone crab claws that are served chilled with a side of mustard sauce.

The restaurant is permanently closed, but its legacy lives on through the numerous reviews that it has received throughout the years. With a rating of 4.3 out of 112 reviews, Rusty Anchor has proven to be a favorite among locals and tourists alike.

One reviewer notes that "Rusty Anchor has been an icon in their neighborhood for decades, closed and now reopened by another iconic restaurant in the area. Breakfast, heretofore not an option, is what drew me in. It is fair to say that the restaurant has not been remodeled but renewed." The reviewer also mentions that the steak and eggs were cooked to perfection.

Another reviewer raves about the restaurant's grouper, saying that it is "awesome." They also praise the cooks for their skill in preparing the dishes and the overall environment of the restaurant.

A third reviewer gives Rusty Anchor high marks for its service, saying that the staff is "super nice." They also compliment the restaurant's Cuban cuisine.

If you're looking for a dining spot that's good for a quick coffee or a place to sit and chill, Rusty Anchor might not be the best option. However, if you're on the hunt for a restaurant that offers amazing seafood, great environment, and tasty beverages, Rusty Anchor is definitely worth checking out.

Nearby landmarks include the Key West Butterfly and Nature Conservatory, the Key West Lighthouse and Keeper's Quarters Museum, and the Ernest Hemingway Home and Museum. Rusty Anchor is a great spot for couples looking for a romantic dinner or families in search of a casual dining experience.

Overall, Rusty Anchor is a classic seafood restaurant that offers a dining experience that is second to none. Although the restaurant is permanently closed, its legacy will live on in the hearts and minds of those who have had the pleasure of dining there.

Stock Island Restaurants

Rusty Anchor