Coney Island Pizza

Coney Island Pizzeria: A Family-owned Gem Serving Authentic NY-style Pizza in Poway

Located at 12233 Poway Rd in Poway, California, Coney Island Pizzeria is a family-owned pizza restaurant that specializes in serving authentic NY-style pizza baked in a stone oven. The restaurant has garnered a rating of 4.6 out of 181 reviews on Google, making it one of the most popular pizza places in the area. Although the restaurant is now permanently closed, it is still remembered fondly by locals and visitors alike for its delicious pizza, friendly staff, and cozy atmosphere.

Cuisine Type and Menu Items

Coney Island Pizzeria is a pizza restaurant that serves red and white pies baked in a stone oven, in addition to garlic knots and salads. The menu features classic pizza toppings like pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, and onions, as well as creative combinations like buffalo chicken, pesto, and BBQ pulled pork. Customers can order pizza by the slice or opt for a whole pie to share with friends and family. The restaurant also offers catering services for events and parties.

Chef and Staff

The restaurant is a family-owned business, and it is run by the owners themselves. They take pride in using fresh ingredients and making the pizza dough from scratch. The staff is friendly and welcoming, and they make customers feel at home from the moment they walk in the door.

Interesting Landmarks Near By

Coney Island Pizzeria is located in Oak Knoll Plaza, a shopping center in Poway that features a variety of stores and restaurants. Other nearby landmarks include the Poway Community Park, the Poway Center for the Performing Arts, and the Blue Sky Ecological Reserve.

Good for: Family Restaurant, Quick Bite, Lunch Spot

Coney Island Pizzeria is an excellent choice for families and groups looking for a casual dining experience. The restaurant has a friendly and laid-back atmosphere, and the staff is accommodating to customers of all ages. The restaurant is also a great option for people looking for a quick bite or a lunch spot during the workweek.

Decor and Ambiance

The restaurant has a classic and cozy ambiance, with red and white checkered tablecloths and vintage posters adorning the walls. The aroma of freshly baked pizza fills the air, and customers can watch as the pizza is prepared and cooked in front of them.

Top Dish in Neighborhood: Pepperoni and Ricotta Pizza

One of the most popular dishes at Coney Island Pizzeria is the pepperoni and ricotta pizza. The combination of savory pepperoni and creamy ricotta cheese on a crispy crust is a crowd-pleaser and a must-try for anyone visiting the restaurant.

Event Space: Catering Services Available

Coney Island Pizzeria offers catering services for events and parties, making it a great choice for people looking to host a gathering with delicious food. The restaurant can accommodate a variety of dietary restrictions and preferences, so customers can customize their catering order to fit their needs.

Health and Organic: Fresh Ingredients and Homemade Dough

The restaurant takes pride in using fresh ingredients and making the pizza dough from scratch, which makes it a great option for people looking for healthy and organic food choices. The restaurant also offers salads and vegetarian options for customers with dietary restrictions.

In conclusion, Coney Island Pizzeria is a family-owned gem in Poway that serves authentic NY-style pizza in a cozy and welcoming atmosphere. Although the restaurant is now closed, it is still remembered fondly by locals and visitors alike for its delicious pizza, friendly staff, and classic ambiance. Whether you're looking for a quick bite, a family restaurant, or a catering service for your next event, Coney Island Pizzeria is a great choice.