Captain's Pizza

Captain's Pizza: Shelton's Best Pizza Joint

If you're looking for a casual spot with great pizza, pasta, and calzones, Captain's Pizza in Shelton, CT is the place to be. Located at 515 Bridgeport Ave, this restaurant offers a laid-back atmosphere with booth seating and a bar, all in neutral tones. With a solid rating of 4.2 out of 280 Google reviews, it's clear that Captain's Pizza is a local favorite.

The menu at Captain's Pizza is focused on classic Italian dishes, with a Greek twist. Customers rave about the Greek-style pizzas, made with only the freshest, high-quality ingredients. Some of the standout dishes on the menu include the Greek Gyros, which are said to be some of the best in the area, and the amazing pizza.

The chef at Captain's Pizza is skilled at crafting delicious Italian dishes that will satisfy any craving. The restaurant is perfect for casual dining with friends and family, as well as business lunches. The pizza joint is a popular spot for couples and groups looking for a quick bite or a sit-and-chill experience.

One of the great things about Captain's Pizza is its location. The restaurant is located near some interesting landmarks, such as the Shelton Dog Park and the Plumb Memorial Library. Whether you're a local or a tourist, Captain's Pizza is a great place to stop by for a bite to eat.

The reviews for Captain's Pizza are largely positive, with many customers praising the food and atmosphere. One customer wrote, "Best pizza in the area. Been to nearly every place in and around Shelton and Captain's Pizza continues to remain my favorite year after year. They have excellent entrees and some of my favorite salads in the area in addition to their amazing pizza. Friendly staff and owner too." Another customer said, "Their Greek Gyros ?? are some of the best I’ve ever had and I’ve been to a lot of Greek festivals and diners, and none compare. Nice long thick shards of lamb pita ?? very packed and filling. The steak fries were right on the money??. Restaurant has great atmosphere as well would suggest anyone looking for Greek food when in the area to stop here. Their pizza ?? is really good too ??."

While most of the reviews are positive, there have been a few negative experiences. For example, one customer wrote, "Have been a customer for 16 years I WILL NEVER GO BACK!!!! I had a few problems the last couple of times. This Sat took the cake. Ordered at 5:15. Girl said 25 mins... you knew that was a lie. Had to pick it up because after 16 years they no longer deliver to me. We got there at 5:45. Did not leave until 6:20. Got all the way home. EVERY pizza was burnt. Pasta dish wrong the large salad was a small with no cheese that we paid extra for. I called and spoke to the manager who basically was rude and said he didn't care. Told me to place the food on my porch and they would send new food back once they see it.... WHAT???? So I should wait another 2 hours??? We ate the burnt pizzas and I told him he could pick up the pasta and salad. He did at 9:00PM.... So glad we weren't waiting for that!!!! This is the WORST customer service ever. I told him doesn't he care about the customers that have been loyal to him through Covid and everything and he said I have plenty. Who cares about you. Really nice...."

Overall, Captain's Pizza is a great spot for casual Italian dining with a Greek twist. With delicious food and a laid-back atmosphere, it's no wonder why this pizza joint has such a solid rating. If you're in the Shelton area, be sure to stop by and try their amazing pizza and other tasty dishes.