Highest-rated Pizza Restaurants in the Orlando Area by Diners
Stacker compiled a list of the highest-rated pizza places in the Orlando area based on diners' reviews on Yelp as of February 2025.
Invalid DateRead more
Tomasino's Pizza
4.4(998 reviews)Google Rating
• ItalianAbout Tomasino's Pizza
Family photos line the walls of this casual eatery specializing in New York-style pizza.
Photos
In the News
Recent articles and mentions about Tomasino's Pizza
6 pizza spots you’ve GOT to try in Orlando
From New York-style to deep dish and coal-fired to artisanal, there's a little something for everyone in Orlando!
Invalid DateRead more
Clean bills of health: Which Central Florida restaurants had perfect inspections in December?
After 1520 restaurant inspections across Central Florida in December, only 156 had no issues for the entire month, according to data from...
Invalid DateRead more
A Local’s Favorite Places for Pizza in Orlando
Grab a slice of our favorite pizza in Orlando with local picks and must-visit pizza spots for a fun and casual date.
Invalid DateRead more
Pizza Bracket Results: Meet the Others in the Superb 16
Twenty-two years after its debut in a refurbished former car repair shop along Summerlin Avenue, Anthony's Thornton Park remains a...
Invalid DateRead more
2020 Orlando Pizza Bracket Challenge
We've picked 32 restaurants in the Orlando area that are known for their pizzas. Each week we'll have the eateries going head to head (think...
Invalid DateRead more
Highlights
✓
Rating:1.020 reviews
✓
Price range:$10–20 Italian restaurant
✓
Description:Family photos line the walls of this casual eatery specializing in New York-style pizza.
✓
Located in:Colonial Plaza
✓
Address:2612 E Colonial Dr, Orlando, FL 32803, United States
✓
Hours:Open ⋅ Closes 9 pm
Similar Places
Pizzeria Del-Dio Italian Restaurant• Italian
Tomasino's Pizza Lake Nona• Italian
Lazy Moon Pizza• Pizza
Domino's Pizza• Pizza Delivery
Business Information
Location
Loading map...