Gotham Bagels

Gotham Bagels: Authentic New York Style Bagels in the Heart of Chicago

Gotham Bagels is a bagel shop located in the heart of Chicago, at 1212 N Dearborn St. This place is a must-visit for bagel lovers who are looking for authentic, handmade New York style bagels. Gotham has been serving bagels for more than twenty years, and they make their bagels the traditional way – mixing the ingredients in-house, rolling by hand, kettle-boiling, and baking in a rotating deck oven.

The menu at Gotham Bagels features a variety of gourmet sandwich creations, house-smoked white fish, thin-sliced pastrami, and premium smoked salmon. They also offer the finest pickles in the country and traditionally mixed tuna fish salad. Customers can place their orders online between 8 am and 1 pm Wednesday through Sunday. Gotham Bagels will send a text message when the order is ready for pickup.

Chef Profile:

Although the restaurant does not have a designated chef, the bagels are handmade and prepared with care by the expert staff at Gotham Bagels.

Menu items:

• Gourmet sandwich creations
• House-smoked white fish
• Thin-sliced pastrami
• Premium smoked salmon
• Finest pickles in the country
• Traditionally mixed tuna fish salad

Nearby Landmarks:

Gotham Bagels is situated in the Gold Coast neighborhood, which is known for its upscale shopping, dining, and nightlife. Landmarks nearby include the Chicago History Museum, the Lincoln Park Zoo, and the Magnificent Mile shopping district.

Reviews:

Gotham Bagels has a rating of 3.9 out of 144 reviews on Google. Customers have praised the restaurant for its authentic New York style bagels and gourmet sandwich creations. However, some reviewers have noted that the prices are high, and the bagels can be quite salty.

One reviewer wrote, "As long as price is of no concern, I would recommend trying Gotham Bagels. The OMFG bagel with spicy chicken was big with good flavor, but unfortunately, it's hard to justify getting it again at that price."

Another reviewer commented, "Moving to Chicago from NYC, it's been tough finding good bagels, but Gotham Bagels has become a regular spot for us. The bread is so chewy and flavorful, and the scallion cream cheese is a must. We always order a dozen for brunch parties a day ahead and pick up the morning of."

Overall, the reviews suggest that Gotham Bagels is a great place for bagel lovers who are looking for an authentic New York style bagel, but the prices may be a bit steep for some customers.

Service Options:

Gotham Bagels offers online ordering for pickup, carryout, and curbside pickup. Customers can place their orders between 8 am and 1 pm Wednesday through Sunday.

Recommendation:

Gotham Bagels is a great place for couples, families, and groups of friends who are looking for an authentic New York style bagel experience. The restaurant is not ideal for a business lunch or a quick coffee stop, as the online ordering system may require some planning ahead. However, if you are looking for a cozy spot to sit and chill while enjoying a delicious bagel, Gotham Bagels is the perfect choice.

In terms of decor, Gotham Bagels is a classic bagel shop with a simple and cozy interior. The restaurant is not a celebrity hangout or a place to be seen, but it is a neighborhood gem that offers some of the best bagels in the city.

Overall, Gotham Bagels is a top contender for the best bagel shop in the Gold Coast neighborhood. If you are a fan of authentic New York style bagels, Gotham Bagels is a must-visit.