New Bethel Ordinary

New Bethel Ordinary: A Pizza Haven in Wanamaker

Located in the small town of Wanamaker, a short drive outside of Indianapolis, New Bethel Ordinary is a beloved pizza spot that has been serving up delicious pies since 1984. With a rating of 4.5 out of 2018 reviews on Google, it's clear that this family-owned restaurant has won the hearts (and stomachs) of many.

The menu at New Bethel Ordinary is a pizza lover's dream, featuring classics like pepperoni and sausage, as well as more unique toppings like BBQ chicken, jalapenos, and pineapple. The restaurant also offers a variety of appetizers and salads, as well as a selection of beer and wine.

The chef at New Bethel Ordinary is known for using quality ingredients to create pizzas with amazing flavor and generous portion sizes. One reviewer raves, "This is the best pizza we have tasted in the Indy area. I highly recommend this restaurant."

While the atmosphere is quaint and comfortable, with big screen TVs and plenty of tables and booths, it's the pizza that steals the show. As one reviewer notes, "The pizza looks nice and has plenty of cheese and toppings." Another reviewer mentions the "stacked pizzas" that are a must-try.

New Bethel Ordinary is a great spot for a casual meal with family or friends, but it's also a popular place for a quick lunch or dinner on the go. The restaurant offers dine-in and curbside pickup options, but unfortunately, they do not offer delivery at this time.

If you're in the area, be sure to check out some of the nearby landmarks, like the Southeastway Park or the Indianapolis Southside Harley-Davidson dealership. And with such rave reviews, it's clear that New Bethel Ordinary should be on your list of places to visit.