Brooklyn Square Pizza

Brooklyn Square Pizza: A Slice of Down-to-Earth Italian Fare in Jackson Township

At Brooklyn Square Pizza, customers can indulge in a classic pizzeria experience with a down-to-earth vibe. This local pizzeria, with locations in Jackson, Manalapan Township, and Toms River, NJ, offers a menu of Italian fare, including pasta, panini, and chicken marsala, but it's their pizza that steals the show.

The star of the menu is the square pizza, with a crust that's pillowy and soft, yet crispy on the outside. Customers rave about the sesame seed crust, which is flavorful and adds a unique twist to the classic pizza. The toppings are simple but delicious, with options like cheese, pepperoni, and mushroom/onion. Customers also have the option of choosing between hand-tossed or Sicilian crust.

While the pizza is the main draw, Brooklyn Square Pizza also offers other Italian staples like pasta and panini. The chicken marsala is a standout, with tender chicken in a rich marsala sauce. The panini options are also noteworthy, with options like the classic Italian and the chicken parm.

Located at 265 S New Prospect Rd in Jackson Township, Brooklyn Square Pizza is situated near several landmarks, including the Jackson Premium Outlets and Six Flags Great Adventure. The restaurant offers dine-in, takeaway, and no-contact delivery options.

Reviews for Brooklyn Square Pizza are overwhelmingly positive, with a 4.4 rating out of 1142 reviews on Google. Customers praise the pizza's unique crust, simple but delicious toppings, and friendly service. One customer even called it one of New Jersey's top pizza spots.

However, there are a few negative reviews, with some customers noting that the pizza can be expensive and that the premade dough can be doughy in the center. Despite this, most customers agree that Brooklyn Square Pizza is a solid choice for a classic pizzeria experience.

Overall, Brooklyn Square Pizza offers a no-frills, down-to-earth dining experience with delicious pizza and Italian fare. It's a great spot for a casual date night or a family dinner, and the friendly service makes customers feel right at home.