Highest-rated Pizza Restaurants in the Binghamton Area by Diners
Stacker compiled a list of the highest-rated pizza places in the Binghamton area based on diners' reviews on Yelp as of February 2025.
Located in the heart of Binghamton, Cortese Restaurant has been a staple in the community since it was founded in 1947 by Angeline Cortese and her sons James and Nathan. Today, this long-running Italian fixture continues to delight locals and visitors alike with its classic Italian cuisine served in warm, dimly lit digs.
As soon as you step inside, you're greeted with the aroma of fresh-baked bread and simmering tomato sauce. The décor is classic and cozy, with dark wood paneling, white tablecloths, and soft lighting that creates a romantic ambiance perfect for a date night or intimate dinner with friends.
The menu is filled with Italian staples like pasta, pizza, seafood, and steak, as well as weekly family specials that showcase the chef's creativity and dedication to using fresh, seasonal ingredients. Recommended dishes include the world-famous pizza, which is saucy and flavorful with just the right amount of cheese, and the Toscana bread, which is so delicious you'll want to order three more.
For main courses, the steak in a king cut with the special house sauce is a must-try. The steak is cooked to perfection, but be aware that it has a lot of fat and is drowning in juices. Another favorite is the veal, which is cooked very well but could use more flavor. If you're in the mood for seafood, the seafood fra diavolo is a spicy, satisfying dish that will leave you feeling warm and full.
The service at Cortese is top-notch, with polite and attentive waitstaff that make you feel like a valued guest. The restaurant also offers outdoor seating in the summer, which is a great way to enjoy the warm weather while savoring delicious Italian food.
Nearby landmarks include the historic Roberson Museum and Science Center, which is just a few blocks away, and the Binghamton Zoo at Ross Park, which is a short drive from the restaurant.
Overall, Cortese Restaurant is a great spot for couples looking for a romantic dinner, families seeking an authentic Italian meal, and anyone looking for classic Italian cuisine in a cozy setting. While some reviewers have found certain dishes to be lacking in flavor or texture, most patrons rave about the restaurant's warm atmosphere, excellent service, and mouth-watering dishes that keep them coming back for more.
Recent articles and mentions about Cortese Restaurant
Stacker compiled a list of the highest-rated pizza places in the Binghamton area based on diners' reviews on Yelp as of February 2025.
Greater Binghamton is known for its plentiful cuisine options. From the beloved spiedie to homemade Italian meals, several dishes have...
Peter J. Putano Sr., 90, of Johnson City, died Jan. 31.
Joan A. Cortese Binghamton - Joan Alice (Pavlick) Cortese, 89 of Binghamton, NY, went to be with the Lord after a long illness on...
Uncover the inspiring story of Whole in the Wall Restaurant in Binghamton, a true pioneer in the smoke-free movement since 1980.
12 Binghamton locations for an ideal date that are in compliance with a student friendly budget. By Eli Engler - February 11, 2024
Hours information not available
117 Robinson St
Binghamton, NY
Loading map...