Athenian Greek Taverna

Athenian Greek Taverna: A Commack Gem for Traditional Greek Fare

Located at 2188 Jericho Turnpike in Commack, Athenian Greek Taverna is a cozy and welcoming restaurant that serves up classic Greek dishes in generous portions. With a rating of 4.2 out of 574 reviews, this local gem has been a favorite among residents for years.

The menu at Athenian Greek Taverna boasts a range of traditional Greek dishes, including moussaka, spanakopita, gyro, and pastitsio. Chef Janni's specialties include his succulent lamb chops and his deliciously seasoned gyros. The restaurant also offers a variety of seafood dishes, such as grilled octopus and shrimp saganaki.

Despite mixed reviews, Athenian Greek Taverna has won over the hearts of many diners. Some reviewers have praised the restaurant for its flavorful dishes and generous portions. One reviewer raves about the "perfectly seasoned" Janni gyro, while another notes that their Greek salad was "still a very generous portion." However, some diners have criticized the restaurant for being too oily or salty, with one reviewer stating that the lemon potatoes were "extremely oily and salty." It's worth noting that several reviewers have also expressed dissatisfaction with the restaurant's pricing and portion sizes.

While Athenian Greek Taverna may not be the perfect dining spot for everyone, it's undoubtedly a great place to enjoy hearty and authentic Greek cuisine. The restaurant's cozy and homey vibe makes it an ideal spot for a casual lunch or dinner with friends and family. Couples looking for a romantic evening out may find the restaurant's decor lacking, but the delicious food more than makes up for it.

Athenian Greek Taverna is conveniently located near several local landmarks, including the Commack Public Library and the Indian Head Golf Park. The restaurant is also just a short drive away from the scenic Caleb Smith State Park Preserve, making it a great spot to grab a bite after a day of hiking or nature-watching.

In summary, Athenian Greek Taverna is a must-visit spot for anyone looking to indulge in traditional Greek fare in Commack. While the restaurant may not be perfect, its generous portions and flavorful dishes make it a great option for anyone craving a hearty and authentic meal.