Have you tried the #1 Mexican restaurant in Ithaca yet? See the top 7 of 2025, according to customers.
Stacker compiled a list of the highest-rated Mexican restaurants in the Ithaca area using data from Yelp.
MSNRead more
Popular For
margaritasfajitasportion sizechimichangabartenderfairtaco saladpartyarroz con polloseafood
Photos
In the News
Recent articles and mentions about Old Mexico
More Mexican — Old Mexico Joins Wealth of Tastefully-Prepared Mexican Cuisine
It's a wonderful restaurant serving an extensive selection of tastefully prepared authentic Mexican fare, attractively presented, and at very reasonable prices.
Ithaca TimesRead more
Brothers to open ‘Old Mexico’ restaurant at former Manos Diner site in Ithaca
The site of the recently closed Manos Diner off of Route 13 in Ithaca will be filled by a Mexican restaurant named “Old Mexico,” according to ownership.
The Ithaca VoiceRead more
Highest-rated Mexican Restaurants in the Elmira Area by Diners
Just like cuisine from any country, Mexican food is not monolithic. It isn't just combo plates and tacos. (Not that there's anything wrong...
StackerRead more
Old Mexico takes over a familiar spot on Route 13 in Ithaca’s southwest
Plan on spending $5-10 on lunch or $10-20 on dinner. Find Old Mexico at 357 Elmira Road or oldmexicoithaca.com, or call 607-379-6178 and tell them you heard...
14850.comRead more
Immigrant arrested by ICE in Ithaca has been deported seven times before, federal prosecutors argue
ITHACA, N.Y. (WSYR-TV) — An undocumented immigrant arrested in Ithaca this week had been deported to Mexico at least seven times prior to...
WSYRRead more
Opening Hours
Hours information not available
Business Information
Available Services
✓ Dine-in✓ Takeout✓ Delivery✓ Curbside
Rating Distribution
★★★★★
997
★★★★★
365
★★★★★
105
★★★★★
39
★★★★★
71
♿ Accessibility
- ✓ Wheelchair accessible entrance
- ✓ Wheelchair accessible parking lot
- ✓ Wheelchair accessible restroom
357 Elmira Rd
Ithaca, NY
Location
Loading map...
