Shelly Pie

Shelly Pie Pizza: A Neighborhood Gem for Italian Favorites

Located on 912 Penn Ave in Turtle Creek, Shelly Pie Pizza has become a local favorite for their super-sized pizzas and Italian favorites. This BYOB restaurant is perfect for a relaxed night out with friends and family, with several flat-screens for entertainment.

The menu at Shelly Pie Pizza offers a wide variety of options, from classic cheese pizza to stuffed calzones. Customers rave about the quality of ingredients and flavors, with many noting the generous portion sizes and affordable prices. The EBUT pie and garlic knots are a standout favorite, with one customer describing it as an "insanely huge" but delicious meal.

While the restaurant has received some negative reviews about undercooked crusts and toppings sliding off, the majority of customers have had positive experiences. The staff is often praised for their friendly and efficient service, with one reviewer even giving them a perfect rating for their attentiveness despite a busy evening.

The restaurant is situated near several landmarks, such as the Turtle Creek Valley Historical Society and the George Westinghouse Bridge. The relaxed atmosphere and affordable prices make it a great spot for a casual night out with friends or family.

Overall, Shelly Pie Pizza is a great option for those looking for delicious Italian food in a relaxed setting. While there may be some inconsistencies in the quality of the crust, the generous portion sizes and friendly staff make it a worthwhile dining experience.