Little Pie Company

Little Pie Company: A Hidden Gem for Pie Lovers in New York City

Nestled in the heart of the Theater District, Little Pie Company is a no-frills bakery that specializes in scratch-made pies in three sizes, plus cakes, cookies, and muffins. With a 4.5 rating out of 923 web reviews, this quaint pie shop has quickly become a favorite among locals and tourists alike.

The menu at Little Pie Company is a pie lover's dream come true. From classic flavors like cherry, and pecan to unique options like sour cream apple walnut and Mississippi mud, there is a pie for every taste bud. The signature apple pie with sour cream and nuts is a must-try and, according to many reviewers, the best apple pie they have ever had. The bakery also offers sugar-free options for those who are watching their sugar intake.

In addition to pies, Little Pie Company also serves delicious cakes, cookies, and muffins. Reviewers rave about the moist and flavorful cakes, with the NY-style cheesecake being a standout. The bakery's brownies, bread pudding, and apple turnovers are also highly recommended.

The bakery is run by a team of talented bakers, but no chef is named on the website or menu. However, the quality of the baked goods speaks for itself. Everything is made from scratch, using only fresh, honest, pure ingredients mixed together by hand in a thoughtful way, with no artificial preservatives.

Little Pie Company is a takeout and delivery-only establishment, with no sit-down dining options. However, the bakery's location in the Theater District makes it a convenient stop for a quick bite before or after a show. The bakery is also surrounded by several landmarks, including the iconic Times Square, the Intrepid Sea, Air & Space Museum, and the Hudson River Greenway.

While the bakery is not a full-service restaurant, it is an excellent choice for couples or families looking for a sweet treat after a day of sightseeing or a quick bite before a show. With its no-frills decor and friendly staff, Little Pie Company is a great place to grab a quick coffee and a muffin or to sit and chill with a slice of pie and a scoop of ice cream.

The bakery's fast service makes it a great option for a business lunch or a brunch with friends. And for those looking for a venue for a party or event, Little Pie Company offers a wide selection of pies and desserts that are sure to impress guests.

While the bakery is not specifically marketed as a vegan or organic establishment, many of the ingredients used in their baked goods are natural and pure. Reviewers note that the pies and cakes taste fresh and natural, without the greasiness or artificial taste that can be found in other bakeries.

In terms of decor, Little Pie Company is a classic, no-frills bakery. The space is small, with a few tables and chairs for customers who wish to sit and enjoy their treats. The walls are adorned with vintage pie tins and baking utensils, giving the space a charming, old-fashioned feel.

In conclusion, Little Pie Company is a must-visit for anyone who loves pie or baked goods. With its scratch-made pies, delicious cakes, and friendly staff, this hidden gem in the Theater District is quickly becoming a favorite among locals and tourists alike. Whether you're looking for a quick coffee and muffin or a slice of pie and ice cream, Little Pie Company is the perfect place to satisfy your sweet tooth.